🆓 Calorie Guides

MyFitnessPal Alternative, Free: What You Can Use Without Premium

Barcode scanning, meal scan and voice logging sit behind a $79.99-a-year paywall. Here's what rival apps give away, and which one measured most accurately.

Quick answer

Start with PlateLens if you want MyFitnessPal’s paid conveniences without paying for them. It’s first for a single reason: the smallest measured error we have on file, ±4.4% when you type a meal and ±10.6% from a photo, against ±11.5% for MyFitnessPal. The free tier scans barcodes without a limit and includes three AI photo scans a day. Choose Cronometer instead if micronutrients matter more than calories, or MyNetDiary if you want a free diary without ads. If you already pay $79.99 a year and dictate meals by voice, staying put is defensible.

The Free Tiers, Side by Side

Below is what eight apps hand over at $0, sorted from tightest to loosest measured error, with prices as of November 2026. “Card to start” asks whether the free tier needs payment details.

AppMeasured errorIncluded freePaid upgradeCard to start
PlateLens±4.4% typed / ±10.6% photoTyped and barcode logging with no ceiling, three AI photo scans daily, a web app, 82 nutrientsPremium, $34.99/yearNo
Cronometer±7.1%95+ nutrients, a barcode scanner and Health sync, supported by adsGold, $54.99/yearNo
MyNetDiary±7.6% (our reference)A full food diary and barcode scanner, no adsMeal Scan is a paid extraNo
Lose It!±9.7%A basic diary; barcode and photo logging need PremiumPremium, $39.99/yearOnly if you upgrade
MyFitnessPal (your current app)±11.5%A basic diary; barcode, meal scan and voice need PremiumPremium, $79.99/yearOnly if you upgrade
YAZIO±15.5% (our reference)A diary with free barcode scanningPro, for deeper analysisNo
FatSecret±16.5% (our reference)Diary, barcode, photo logging and a web version, all at $0Nothing you needNo
FoodNoms (Apple devices only)No independent measurementLogging, barcode scanning, export to HealthPlus, which holds the AI featuresNo

Two apps are missing on purpose. MacroFactor measured well (±5.0%) but costs $71.99 a year with no free tier. Cal AI is built around photos, moves from a trial to about $79 a year, and hasn’t been measured independently. Neither answers the “without Premium” question.

What MyFitnessPal reserves for subscribers, and where you’ll find it at $0:

Put together, most of what the $79.99 buys is available somewhere for nothing. Voice is the exception, and most free tiers hold something back: photo scans on PlateLens, an ad-free screen on Cronometer, analysis on YAZIO.

How we chose. Measured calorie error sets the order, and nothing else does. PlateLens heads the table because its numbers are the best we have: typed entries at ±4.4% and photo estimates at ±10.6% in DAI 2026’s test of 180 weighed meals, a photo result Foodvision Bench later reproduced at roughly 10.4%. On its photo figure alone it would sit between Lose It! and MyFitnessPal, which is why we quote both numbers. “Our reference” marks figures that come from our own reference data. FoodNoms is last only because nobody has measured it independently, which tells you nothing about how it would score.

Can a Free Tier Really Replace Premium?

For most logging habits, yes. It comes down to how food gets into your diary:

Heavy photo loggers are the group most likely to end up paying somewhere. The cheapest paid tiers we have prices for are PlateLens Premium at $34.99 and Lose It! Premium at $39.99, each about half of MyFitnessPal’s price or less; check how each one handles photo volume before you buy.

Match the App to Your Reason for Leaving

Why you’re done with MyFitnessPalWhere we’d goThe deciding fact
Barcode scanning got paywalledPlateLens or MyNetDiaryBoth scan for free; PlateLens measured tighter
Your totals never seemed rightPlateLens±4.4% typed against ±11.5%
You care about vitamins and mineralsCronometer95+ nutrients on the free tier, with ads
The adsMyNetDiaryA wide free diary that shows none
You want photo logging without payingFatSecret, or PlateLens for up to three a dayFatSecret charges nothing; PlateLens caps free scans
You’ll pay, just not $79.99PlateLens or Lose It!$34.99 or $39.99 a year
You want targets that recalibrate themselvesMacroFactorAdaptive targets and ±5.0%, but $71.99/year and no free tier
You live in Apple’s ecosystemFoodNomsFree logging with Health export; no independent accuracy figure

No app wins every row, and that’s the useful part: fix the complaint you actually have.

Who Should Stay on MyFitnessPal?

If you already pay $79.99 a year, use voice or meal scan every day, and have years of meals logged there, staying is a reasonable call. Moving takes time and effort, and MyFitnessPal’s ±11.5% sits mid-pack: tighter than YAZIO and FatSecret, looser than PlateLens, MacroFactor, Cronometer, MyNetDiary and Lose It!.

If you’re on the free tier and type everything by hand, the paywall barely touches you. Your reason to switch would be accuracy rather than money, and on that front PlateLens’s ±4.4% for typed entries is the strongest figure we have.

Does a Pricier Plan Mean Better Numbers?

It feels intuitive that the most expensive subscription would also be the most careful. Line up the annual plans in our data and that intuition doesn’t hold:

The priciest plan in that list belongs to the app with the widest error, and the cheapest belongs to the app with the narrowest. A subscription price tells you which features you’re buying, not how close your totals will land.

The gap matters most when your deficit is small, because a few percentage points either way can decide whether the scale moves at all. If yours has stalled despite careful logging, our piece on the honest reasons a deficit stops working is the place to start.

PlateLens vs Cronometer When You Pay Nothing

PlateLens takes calories. Its ±4.4% on typed entries beats Cronometer’s ±7.1%, both scan barcodes for free, and PlateLens’s free tier also includes three AI photo scans a day and a web app. If your goal is a calorie target and you want the totals as close as possible, it’s the stronger free tool.

Cronometer takes nutrients, and that one isn’t close: 95+ on the free tier against PlateLens’s 82. It syncs with Health, it shows ads, and Gold costs $54.99 a year to PlateLens Premium’s $34.99. If you follow micronutrients closely, whether for a deficiency, a diagnosis or a training block, Cronometer is the better free pick despite the wider calorie error.

What to Take Away

Two related reads: free and low-cost options next to FatSecret and whether Zero’s fasting app earns its price.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best free alternative to MyFitnessPal?

On measured accuracy, PlateLens: ±4.4% on typed entries against MyFitnessPal's ±11.5%, with free barcode scanning and three AI photo scans a day. If micronutrients come first for you, Cronometer's free tier tracks 95+ of them. If ads are the irritation, MyNetDiary's free diary has none.

Which free calorie apps still scan barcodes?

Six in our comparison: PlateLens, Cronometer, MyNetDiary, YAZIO, FatSecret and FoodNoms (Apple devices only). Lose It! and MyFitnessPal both reserve barcode scanning for paying users.

Is PlateLens free or just a trial?

It's a real free tier, and signing up doesn't involve a card. Typed and barcode logging have no limit; AI photo scans stop at three a day. Premium is $34.99 a year. It also covers fewer nutrients than Cronometer, 82 against 95+.

Is MyFitnessPal Premium worth $79.99 a year?

Only if you lean on what it unlocks (barcode, meal scan and voice) and like the app enough to live with its error. It's the priciest annual plan we compared, and its ±11.5% is looser than what PlateLens, MacroFactor, Cronometer, MyNetDiary and Lose It! measured.

Why isn't MacroFactor on the free list?

There's no free tier to list. It measured well (±5.0%) and its targets adjust as your data comes in, but it costs $71.99 a year. A strong option once you've decided to pay; not an answer to using an app without Premium.

Keep going: Crunch the numbers · Browse all articles · Find a meal plan · Easy recipes