Cheaper Than FatSecret: Free and Low-Cost Calorie Trackers
FatSecret already costs nothing, so 'cheaper' really means sharper numbers for the same $0, or the smallest bill that's actually worth paying.
You can’t beat FatSecret on price, because FatSecret is free: diary, barcode scanner, photo logging and web version included. What you can get for the same $0 is better accuracy. FatSecret measured ±16.5%, the widest error in our data, while PlateLens’s free tier measured ±4.4% on typed entries, and that gap is the only reason PlateLens leads this page. If you’re willing to pay a little, PlateLens Premium at $34.99 a year is the lowest annual price we have, with Lose It! at $39.99 just behind. Stay with FatSecret if free photo logging matters more to you than tight totals.
What Each App Gives You for $0
Everything here was priced in November 2026. FatSecret comes first as the baseline; the rest run from smallest measured error to largest. “Card?” asks whether you need payment details to use the app the way its row describes.
| App | Costs you nothing for | Card? | Measured error | Paid tier |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| FatSecret (baseline) | Diary, barcode, photo logging, web version | No | ±16.5% (our reference) | Not needed |
| PlateLens | Typing and barcode lookups without a cap, three AI photo scans each day, 82 nutrients, web app | No, sign-up skips it | ±4.4% typed, ±10.6% photo | Premium at $34.99/yr |
| Cronometer | 95+ nutrients, barcode, Health sync, with ads | No | ±7.1% | Gold at $54.99/yr |
| MyNetDiary | An extensive diary plus barcode, ad-free | No | ±7.6% (our reference) | Meal Scan costs extra |
| Lose It! | A basic diary | Yes, for barcode or photo | ±9.7% | Premium at $39.99/yr |
| MyFitnessPal | A basic diary | Yes, for barcode, scan or voice | ±11.5% | Premium at $79.99/yr |
| YAZIO | Diary and barcode | No | ±15.5% (our reference) | Pro unlocks analysis |
| FoodNoms (Apple devices) | Food logging, barcode, export to Health | No | Not independently tested | Plus unlocks the AI tools |
FatSecret’s free column is long, and it deserves a fair hearing:
- The food diary, with no subscription attached.
- Barcode scanning at no charge.
- Photo logging for free, where PlateLens stops at three scans a day and Lose It!, MyFitnessPal and MyNetDiary charge.
- A web version, which PlateLens also offers.
On features per dollar, FatSecret is very hard to beat. On accuracy it’s last among the apps we’ve measured, and that trade is what this page is really about.
How we chose. Measured error decides the order below FatSecret, with unmeasured apps at the bottom. PlateLens leads on that measure alone: DAI 2026 weighed 180 meals and put its typed logging at ±4.4% and its photo estimates at ±10.6%, and Foodvision Bench landed near 10.4% when it repeated the photo test. Figures tagged “our reference” are our own reference numbers, FatSecret’s included.
Why Leave an App That’s Already Free?
Because the cost never shows up on a bill. It shows up in your totals. Take the 2,000-calorie day that US nutrition labels use as a reference, and each app’s measured error works out to roughly:
- FatSecret, ±16.5%: about 330 kcal high or low.
- YAZIO, ±15.5%: about 310 kcal.
- Cronometer, ±7.1%: about 142 kcal.
- PlateLens on typed entries, ±4.4%: about 88 kcal.
A modest deficit can disappear inside a 330-kcal swing, and you can’t tell which days it happened. That’s what FatSecret really costs you, and it’s the strongest reason to move.
Paid Plans, Cheapest First
If $0 isn’t enough, here’s every paid tracker plan we have a confirmed price for, annual plans first and cheapest at the top. YAZIO Pro, MyNetDiary’s Meal Scan, FoodNoms Plus and HealthifyMe’s premium tiers are left out because we don’t have confirmed prices; HealthifyMe’s sit at the expensive end, and it hasn’t been measured independently.
| Plan | Price | Billed | Measured error |
|---|---|---|---|
| PlateLens Premium | $34.99 | Yearly | ±4.4% typed, ±10.6% photo |
| Lose It! Premium | $39.99 | Yearly | ±9.7% |
| Cronometer Gold | $54.99 | Yearly | ±7.1% |
| MacroFactor (paid only) | $71.99 | Yearly | ±5.0% |
| Cal AI (after its trial) | ~$79 | Yearly | Not measured independently |
| MyFitnessPal Premium | $79.99 | Yearly | ±11.5% |
| Fitia premium (Latin America) | ~$8 | Monthly | No figure in our data |
| Nutracheck (UK) | £7.99 | Monthly | No figure in our data |
Monthly plans hide their real size: twelve months of Fitia comes to roughly $96, more than any of the top three annual plans, and twelve of Nutracheck to about £96.
Who Is Better Off Staying With FatSecret?
Anyone who photographs most meals and won’t pay. FatSecret doesn’t charge for photo logging, while PlateLens gives you three free scans a day and Lose It!, MyFitnessPal and MyNetDiary want money for theirs. The same goes for people logging for awareness rather than precision (maintenance, a loose habit check, a curious week), where a ±16.5% error rarely changes what you’d do. And if you like logging at a desk, FatSecret’s web version costs nothing.
Leave if you’re actively cutting, especially on a small deficit, or if you need nutrient detail; Cronometer covers 95+ nutrients without charging and measured ±7.1%. The point of moving isn’t saving money, since there’s none to save. It’s getting totals you trust enough to act on.
Is a Photo Estimate as Good as Typing It In?
Free photo logging is what makes FatSecret’s free tier look generous, so it helps to know what a photo costs in precision. The best-measured app in our data shows the gap plainly:
- PlateLens, typed entries: ±4.4%.
- PlateLens, photo estimates: ±10.6% in DAI 2026, about 10.4% in Foodvision Bench’s repeat.
- FatSecret, overall: ±16.5% (our reference).
- Cal AI, built around photos: no independent measurement.
Even in the app that measured best, a photo estimate is more than twice as loose as a typed entry, and PlateLens’s photo figure is wider than the measured numbers for Cronometer (±7.1%), MyNetDiary (±7.6%) and Lose It! (±9.7%). That doesn’t make photos pointless, since a quick snap beats an entry you never make. For the meals you eat on repeat, though, typing or scanning is the more reliable habit.
If your diary says you’re in a deficit and the scale disagrees, read the common reasons a deficit stalls before you blame your metabolism.
FatSecret vs PlateLens at Zero Dollars
FatSecret wins on what $0 unlocks. Photo logging is free rather than rationed, there’s a web version, and the diary and scanner don’t sit behind a subscription. If your priority is logging lots of meals quickly without ever paying, it’s the more generous free tier.
PlateLens wins on the numbers: ±4.4% typed and ±10.6% photo, both narrower than FatSecret’s ±16.5%, and it has a web app as well. It loses on photo volume (three free scans a day), on cost once you outgrow the free tier ($34.99 a year against FatSecret’s nothing), and on nutrient depth next to Cronometer (82 where Cronometer covers 95+). Pick PlateLens if the total matters; keep FatSecret if the habit matters more than the total.
What to Take Away
- FatSecret can be matched on price, never beaten. It’s free.
- Its real cost is accuracy: ±16.5%, the widest error in our data.
- PlateLens is first only because it measured best. Free photo scanning tops out at three daily, the Premium plan bills $34.99 annually, and it covers 82 nutrients where Cronometer covers 95+.
- The cheapest paid plan we list is PlateLens Premium at $34.99 a year, with Lose It! at $39.99 next.
- Keep FatSecret for free photo logging, web access, or low-stakes tracking.
Keep reading: the free MyFitnessPal alternatives worth a look and our verdict on Zero’s fasting app.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is there a calorie tracker cheaper than FatSecret?
Not in dollars. FatSecret charges nothing for its diary, barcode scanner, photo logging or web version, and you can't get below zero. Several apps tie it at $0 while measuring tighter; PlateLens, Cronometer and MyNetDiary are where we'd look first.
How accurate is FatSecret?
Our reference figure for it is ±16.5%, the widest in our data. Fine for a rough sense of your day; shaky if you're trying to hold a small, steady deficit.
What's the least I can spend on a better tracker?
Of the plans we have prices for, PlateLens Premium is lowest at $34.99 a year, with Lose It!'s Premium plan next at $39.99. Try the free tiers first: you can start PlateLens, Cronometer or MyNetDiary without paying anything.
Is YAZIO a good free swap for FatSecret?
It's a sideways move. Barcode scanning costs nothing, but YAZIO's reference figure is ±15.5%, a single point tighter than FatSecret's, and its analysis features sit behind Pro.
What about trackers made for the UK, India or Latin America?
Nutracheck (UK) is £7.99 a month with a database built around UK food and no meaningful free tier. HealthifyMe (India) is coach-led, and its premium tiers sit at the expensive end. Fitia (Latin America) combines a meal planner with a counter, at about $8 a month for premium. None beats FatSecret on price, and we have no independent accuracy figures for any of the three.
Keep going: Crunch the numbers · Browse all articles · Find a meal plan · Easy recipes